Why Browser 'Do Not Track' Features Won't Work

Why Browser 'Do Not Track' Features Won't Work - PCWorld Business Center News Reviews How-To's Downloads Shop & Compare Apps Business Center NEW Android App Guide iPhone App Guide All PCWorld Blogs » All PCWorld Videos » Cameras Camcorders Cell Phones Components Desktops HDTV Home Theater GPS Laptops Monitors MP3 Players Networking &
Wireless Printers Storage Software Antivirus & Security Browsers & Add-ons Operating Systems Multimedia Utilities Games Popular Topics Consumer Advice Gadgets Gaming Macs & iPods Mobile Security Tech Industry Tech Events Upgrading Windows 7 Featured BrandsShop Lenovo LaptopsShop Acer ProductsAMD Guide to Visual ComputingCisco Small Business MagazineSubscribe & Get a Bonus CD Customer Service

Discover news, guides, and products for your business

Software & ServicesOffice HardwareSecurityServers & StorageCell Phones & MobileOperating SystemsNetworking & VOIPVirtualization Follow us Feeds & Newsletters function submitNewsletterSubscriptionHeaderModule(){var postData=$("#newsletterModuleForm").serialize();var requestOptions={url: '/newsletters/pcw_module_processor',data: postData,success: function(data,textStatus){$("#newsletterSubscribeHeader").fadeOut("slow",function(){$(this).html(data).fadeIn("slow");})}};$.ajax(requestOptions);} Net Work
Practical IT insight from Tony Bradley » More Net Work » RSS » All Blogs Tweet 0 Comments+0 RecommendsEmailPrint Business Center Why Browser 'Do Not Track' Features Won't WorkBy Tony Bradley, PCWorld

Mozilla, Microsoft, and Google have each developed some sort of "do not track" feature for their respective Web browsers. The intent is good, but each solution is fundamentally flawed and is unlikely to work very well in the real world.

Similar Articles:Do-Not-Track in Chrome and Firefox: Different Approaches, Same Fatal FlawMozilla Adds 'Do Not Track' to Newest Firefox 4 BetaFirefox 'Do Not Track' Ready for Download NowDo You Know Who's Tracking You on the Web?Firefox Do-Not-Track Feature Has a Fatal FlawNew Firefox Feature to Block Behavioral Ads

Following the call for action from the United States Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to create some sort of a Web browsing "do not track" list similar to the "do not call" list consumers can use to avoid being harassed by telemarketers, the major browser vendors took some initiative and got to work.

Microsoft announced availability of the Internet Explorer 9 release candidate--the final evaluation version before the official release of the browser. The IE9 RC includes Microsoft's solution to the Web tracking issue. The problem with Microsoft's approach, though, is that it relies too heavily on user intervention--requiring the user essentially to manage which sites should or shouldn't be allowed to track browsing behavior.

Google's approach is not an inherent feature of the Chrome browser, but is offered instead as a "Keep My Opt-Outs" browser extension. Not only does the Google solution require the user to be aware of the extension and add it, but the ability of the extension to thwart online tracking efforts relies on the self-regulating efforts of the advertising companies responsible for the tracking.

Then, there is Mozilla's "do not track" solution. The Mozilla feature has been added to the latest beta release of Firefox 4. If enabled, Firefox will add information to HTTP requests from the browser letting Web sites know that the user wishes not to be tracked...assuming the Web site is paying attention and chooses to care.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) backs the Mozilla solution. An EFF spokesperson e-mailed me to comment. "The Do Not Track approach endorsed by the FTC and now Mozilla is a great idea. It's technically elegant and will serve as a platform for further privacy innovation. Yes, parallel efforts will still be needed to combat online scams, phishing and privacy-invading malware (and also to protect people who don't use Do Not Track) but this is a major step in the right direction."

It may be technically elegant, but it's fatal flaw is that it depends on the Web sites in question to A) be looking for the HTTP header data, and B) be reputable enough to honor the "do not track" request. Those are some major hurdles that make Mozilla's technical elegance impractical in function.

Doug Wolfgram, CEO of IntelliProtect, an online privacy management company, agrees that the Mozilla solution is flawed. Wolfgram e-mailed me to say, "The Mozilla solution is only as effective as the companies who embrace it which so far is none. It appears as though it sets a header, meaning opt out of ALL sites who embrace it or none, no real consumer choice for whom they want to allow to track."

In response to my criticisms of the Mozilla approach, the EFF spokesperson explained, "The tracking we're most worried about is conducted by large third-party domains. These are giant sites that are tracking most of us, most of the time, but we never see them because they're hidden inside iframes and JavaScript beacons in the pages we're looking at. Among those very large domains, we believe it will be comparatively easy to determine which ones do and don't respect the Do Not Track header."

Wolfgram also pointed out another serious obstacle. "Many behavioral targeting companies are based outside the US--making legislation ineffective. Right now, those within the US must voluntarily comply." Wolfgram added that solutions which take an all or nothing approach don't give consumers enough control.

The good news is that the FTC and the major browser vendors are aware that there is a problem and are all actively working on solving it. The bad news is that these initial stabs fall short of the goal, and that it would be better if all parties would agree on a single, standard solution.

Was this article useful? Yes 0 No 0#resourceLinks li {display: none;}Sponsored Resource:Find your perfect All-in-One printing solution from HP.Read more like this: browser security, firefox, internet explorer, privacy

You can follow Tony on hisFacebook page, or contact him by email attony_bradley@pcworld.com. He also tweets as @Tony_BradleyPCW.

Add YoursComments Readers reply with their ideas and expertise.Subscribe to this discussion via email or RSSWhat do you think? Connect with Facebookwindow.onload = function(){ if (displayFBConnect()){$(".fb-login").show();$(".fb-connect-txt").show();}};function displayFBConnect() { var display = (Logon.isValid && FB.Connect.get_loggedInUser())?false:true; return display;} Posting comment ...

Laptop Showcase

Balance Performance and Portability with Lenovo IdeaPads and Thinkpads.

See special offers.

Sponsored AdvertisementWhat's New on Innovators ForumA Community for Small Businesses

How to Find the Right Support CommunityAn IP Voice System Can Save You Money and Grow With Your BusinessReading Partner ContractsThe Help You Need—When You Need ItProtect Your Business From Data Loss With Network StorageJoin the conversation >>

$("#ciscoOOSBlog").click(function(){ window.open("http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;235038711;13346828;e?http://blogs.cisco.com/smallbusiness/;");return false;});Business News Daily

Get the latest technology news that's important to you and your business, fresh seven days a week.

function submitNewsletterSubscription(){var postData=$("#newsletterModuleForm").serialize();var requestOptions={url: '/newsletters/pcw_module_processor',data: postData,success: function(data,textStatus){$("#smbRightSubscribe").fadeOut("slow",function(){$(this).html(data).fadeIn("slow");})}};$.ajax(requestOptions)}Internet downloads Full PackageNow you too can make great money right from your home with your own auto-pilot "Internet Empire"! The ULTIMATE eBUSINESS Ebook With Resale RightsThe ULTIMATE eBUSINESS With Resale Rights Internet's best free softwareCD of the Internet's best free software Download Accelerator Plus Accelerate and more effectively manage your downloads. Full Speed Internet Booster 3.3Full Speed Internet Booster 3.3 Postby admin ?? Thu Jun 03, 2010 9:48 am Full Speed Internet Booster 3.3 Image Full Speed software is the most effective Internet Speed Booster and Internet Speed Test software available today! Just download, run, and click the Boost button. Now you will have 5 X faster Internet, forever!503 more results...Latest in Business Center BlogsNet Work - February 19, 2011 10:57 AM

VIPorbit App Redefines iPhone ProductivityVIPorbit--a new app from one of the co-creators of ACT!--is a game changing app for managing relationships on the iPhone

Security Alert - February 18, 2011 4:30 PM

Your Smartphone: The Next Big Security Headache2011 is the year that mobile security is going mainstream. And while smartphones aren't a major malware target in the United States yet, there are reasons to be concerned about the future of mobile security.

Net Work - February 18, 2011 4:15 PM

Twitter Cracks Down on Popular Mobile AppsTwitter suspended popular services like UberTwitter and twidroyd, claiming that the services violate Twitter policies and trademarks.

BizFeed - February 18, 2011 2:41 PM

BlackBerry Gets the Gist for Contacts Apps BlackBerry has purchased software maker Gist, which offers a nifty app for aggregating information about your contacts with social networking-like features. Will it make Blackberries interesting again?

Security Alert - February 18, 2011 1:51 PM

Watch Out for FDIC Phishing ScamA new phishing scam is circulating claiming to be from the FDIC, and containing a Trojan downloader file attachment.

BizFeed - February 18, 2011 1:09 PM

Amazon S3 Offers Complete Website HostingThe Amazon Simple Storage Service (S3) now allows complete Web hosting, but is it better and cheaper than standard hosting providers?

All Blogs » Top Small Business Ready Products Lenovo ThinkPad W701ds 289 people want this

HP EliteBook 8440w 236 people want this

Lenovo ThinkPad X100e 219 people want this

HP ProBook 5310m 182 people want this

Lenovo ThinkPad SL510 (2847-22U) 156 people want this

See all

Featured Webcasts Top 10 Concerns of Buying a VoIP Business Phone System

Type: whitepaper

Company: CompareBusinessProducts.com

Categories: VOIP

Buying a Phone System? Compare the 94 Business Phone Systems in One Chart

Type: whitepaper

Company: CompareBusinessProducts.com

Categories: VOIP

More webcasts » Free WhitepapersSoftware and Services Whitepapers from PCWorldMore whitepapers » Whitepaper Alerts

Get updates on white papers, case studies, and spotlights on tech products and solutions for your business.

function submitNewsletterSubscriptionWhitepaper(){var postData=$("#newsletterModuleFormWhitepaper").serialize();var requestOptions={url: '/newsletters/pcw_module_processor',data: postData,success: function(data,textStatus){$("#smbWhitepaperAlert").fadeOut("slow",function(){$(this).html(data).fadeIn("slow");})}};$.ajax(requestOptions)} More from the PCWorld BusinessCenter   7 Ways to Avoid Getting Hacked by Anonymous 12 Must-Have Android Apps for Road Warriors Is Google Corrupt? 5 Ways to Make Sure You Aren't the Next Wikileak Employees Have Free Speech on Facebook Six Reasons Not to Buy the Verizon iPhone 4 Social Engineering: 3 Examples of Human Hacking HP TouchPad Tablet Unveiled HP Launches Two New webOS Phones
PCWorld.com is the Web's trusted resource for management-level buyers and users of technology products, reaching an average of more than 11 million unique visitors per month (HitBox, January - June 2009).
More About Us » FAQ »ResourcesTwitterRSSNewslettersContact UsMagazine Customer ServiceAdvertiseNetworkPCWorldPCWorld Business CenterSearch for JobsMacworldMacUserMac OS X HintsiPhone CentralNameCityAddress 1StateZipAddress 2E-mail (optional)Canadian Residents | Foreign Residents | Gift Subscriptions
Customer Service | Privacy Policy© 1998-2009, PCWorld Communications, Inc. Terms of Service Agreement Privacy Policy Community Standards

View the original article here

This post was made using the Auto Blogging Software from WebMagnates.org This line will not appear when posts are made after activating the software to full version.